THE GREAT AUSSIE/NEW ZEALAND MANUKA DISPUTE!!
Leptospermum species comprises 86 recognized subspecies. Only 2 of these are found outside of Australia.
Leptospermum recurvum is found in Sabah, Malaysia and Sulawesi, Indonesia.
New Zealand have just one species of Leptospermum, the Leptospermum scoparium (commonly known as Teatree) which is the exact same one that occurs in Tasmania.
Studies have shown that Leptospermum scoparium originated in Australia and many years ago somehow moved to New Zealand as a result of long-distance dispersal. The weather, including strong winds and cyclones are most likely responsible for the transferal of plant seeds. It is quite feasible that the teatree may have been washed out from an Australian river and into the Tasman sea only to wash ashore on a New Zealand beach…?
At the end of the day the Leptospermum scoparium is found in both Australia and New Zealand. Same plant, same flower, same honey!
MGO vs UMF explained
The first to appear was the UMF (Unique Manuka Factor). This term appeared at a time that no one really knew exactly what it was that gave the Manuka honey its Peroxide Activity (all honeys produce non-Peroxide Activity or TA = Total Activity).
In 1981 A professor at the New Zealand Waikato University by the name of Peter Molan set about researching properties in Manuka honey. After all, Tea Tree oil was already known to have healing qualities.
His research led him to discover that there was in fact this anti-bacterial quality about Manuka honey which in turn the “Unique Manuka Factor” brand was born.
This information was kept close to only those involved so in 2006, Professor Thomas Henle of Dresden University of Technology (Germany) discovered what the actual “magic” ingredient was; Methylglyoxal or MGO as we now know it.
Methylglyoxal holds the antibacterial agent in Manuka honey which is why it has been used for years by professionals to treat wound healing, oral health, gastric ulcers and improve digestives symptoms.
So now we have 2 different trademarked terms that, in their own right have made exceptional discoveries that both show the amazing qualities of Manuka honey and why you see either UMF or MGO on labelling. Some have taken these studies and run with the marketing of Manuka honey almost like a game!
TA – Total Activity
Total Activity is a measure of both Peroxide Activity (PA) as well as Non-Peroxide Activity (NPA). UMF or MGO ratings refer to Methylglyoxal and is a measurement of only NPA found in Manuka honey.
ALF – Active Leatherwood Honey
Enter Leatherwood Honey……
At the completion of harvest, we have all our production tested by a specialist independent laboratory to assess the presence of compounds that give the honey a Total Activity (TA) rating. These compounds generate Hydrogen Peroxide that equates to a hospital grade Phenol disinfectant. We have registered the term Active Leatherwood Factor (ALF) to designate honey that has this special characteristic.
We believe Leatherwood honeys health benefits is as effective if not more than Manuka honey. Below is a statement from one of our staff members.
“The Active Leatherwood is what I have personally used for all cuts and wounds for the whole family as well as livestock on the farm and pets.
Every cut that I have applied Active Leatherwood to nearly vanishes when it heals. Working with roofing sheets one day here, I cut the top of my hand deeply. In amongst the emergency of patching the cut together I thought “what a good opportunity to test Manuka MGO500+ against the Active Leatherwood on the open wound”. So, 2 band aids, 2 types of honey and 2 months later the photo shows the result.
The cut started from the Manuka side and ran deeper all the way across to the knuckle finishing at the third line shown. The side of the cut that we applied Leatherwood too should have had stitches, but opted to just apply the honey, pull the skin together, and use the band aid to hold it all together. You can also see the beginning of the Active Leatherwood side where the Manuka honey was over applied and leaking across to the Active Leatherwood side of the cut.
The Manuka worked great, but the Active Leatherwood just goes that extra mile and has been consistent with every cut I have applied it too”.
|Manuka||Manuka||Active Leatherwood Factor|
|NPA, non-peroxide activity, equivalent New Zealand UMF||MGO (Methylglyoxal mg/kg)||ALF, Total Activity (TA) (NPA + Phenol)|